Helprin got the biggest beating, with his staid conservative opinions being drowned out by his utter contempt for basically anyone without his Ivy League pedigree (read: young people, women, Nascar fans.) There are some good arguments to be sure, but Kakutani lays him out to dry. After citing a lengthy quote from his blathering opus, she brands it a "bullying and pigheaded manifesto." Ouch
Kot gets the better end of the bargain by simply being labeled naive: a wild-eyed idealist who sees the future of media in bands like Death Cab for Cutie. Good luck! Kakutani has spoken. I don't think I'll be reading either of these.
(image from Slate.com)
No comments:
Post a Comment